Actually, this Chicago Now post is a better look into the Handome Men’s Club skit: How Jimmy Kimmel pulled off “Handsome Men’s Club”.
It’s funny, several of them were a little uncomfortable, like, “Just so you know, I don’t think I’m this handsome guy.” Don’t worry. First of all, you are. And secondly, no one is going to think you’re a jerk in this piece. We’ve made Jimmy the ahole in this one, don’t worry about it.